Aluminum Lady HDQ

HDQ ALERT
Loading the latest from HDQ  · 
AS THE CAROUSEL TURNS WATCH COMPANY PULSE CURRENT AFFAIRS HISTORICAL RECORD COMMUNITY VOICES JOIN HDQ
TWA

The Art of the Pillage: Carl Icahn, TWA, and the Corporate Raiders Who Broke America’s Great Companies

Leave a Comment / Historical Record / By

There is a particular kind of predation that does not build anything — that cannot build anything, because building requires patience, care, and a tolerance for uncertainty that the purely extractive mind cannot sustain. Instead, it hunts. It identifies what is already built, assesses the gap between what the whole is worth and what the pieces might fetch if separated, and then moves with cold, deliberate speed that those who love the institution are never quite prepared for. In the 1980s, this predation acquired a polite name — the corporate raider — and in the United States it reshaped industries, destroyed legacies, and left behind a landscape of bankruptcies, broken pensions, and shattered careers. What made it so durable was not ingenuity but impunity: the law permitted it, Wall Street celebrated it, and an entire generation was conditioned to mistake ruthlessness for efficiency and greed for virtue.

The raiders had a vocabulary — efficiency, shareholder value, unlocking hidden worth — borrowed from academic finance and repeated with such conviction that, for a time, even their victims half-believed it. Carl Icahn believed it most of all. He was, by his own account, a disciplinarian, a corrective force applied to bloated institutions that deserved what they got. “I’m not here to make friends,” he told reporters more than once. “I’m here to make money.” He said this not as a confession but as a boast — as though the renunciation of accountability were itself a form of virtue. The airline he chose to prove his thesis on was Trans World Airlines. The proof, when it arrived, took the form of two bankruptcies, 36,500 pension accounts handed over to federal trustees, an eight-year ticket agreement that bled the carrier dry one seat at a time, and a final absorption into American Airlines in 2001, where the surviving employees were stapled to the bottom of the seniority list. It was not mismanagement. It was legalized asset extraction — waged with the airline’s own resources against the airline’s own future.

img 3881

A Company Worth Plundering

Trans World Airlines was not, in 1985, a company in obvious distress. It was a company in manageable difficulty — the kind that competent leadership and patient capital could have addressed. Built from the 1930 merger of Western Air Express and Transcontinental Air Transport, TWA had grown into one of the most recognizable names in American aviation. Howard Hughes, its controlling shareholder from 1939 until he was forced out by creditors in 1960, had made it something more than an airline — a symbol of American ambition, a carrier of presidents, popes, and movie stars. The terminal Hughes commissioned at John F. Kennedy International Airport, designed by Eero Saarinen and completed in 1962, was a cathedral of modern travel, its sweeping concrete wings a declaration that flight was transformation, not merely transportation.

By 1985, TWA was publicly traded, its stock depressed, its management distracted, and its unions locked in the concessionary bargaining cycle that followed the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978. Carl Icahn — fifty years old, a Queens-born financier who had built a reputation buying undervalued companies and forcing changes or collecting greenmail — saw not an airline to rescue but a pile of separable assets: planes, routes, and landing slots that were worth more sold off than managed together.

Icahn was greeted, initially, as a potential savior. The pilots’ union, terrified of Texas Air Corporation’s Frank Lorenzo gaining control — Lorenzo had filed a strategic bankruptcy at Continental Airlines in 1983 specifically to void union contracts — supported Icahn’s bid. The pilots granted him 30 percent wage concessions. The machinists agreed to 15 percent reductions. By August 1985, the TWA board accepted his offer of $24 per share. “When they required my assistance,” Icahn told shareholders, “I retained my $440 million investment and declined a $170 million profit to do so.” He presented himself as a reluctant patriot. Those who worked for him would soon understand what his assistance was actually worth.

The Strike He Engineered

In January 1986, the pilots and machinists ratified their wage cuts, believing Icahn’s explicit assurances that concessions were temporary — a bridge to restored wages, profit-sharing, and ownership stakes. The flight attendants refused. Represented by the Independent Federation of Flight Attendants — a workforce 85 percent female — they faced a package their leaders calculated at 44 percent in combined wage cuts and work-rule changes: a 22 percent pay reduction, plus scheduling modifications that would have required attendants to spend 320 hours per month away from home, up from 240. Union president Victoria Frankovich accused Icahn of applying a sexist assumption — that flight attendants were secondary wage earners whose sacrifice cost nothing.

On March 7, 1986, 6,000 flight attendants walked out. Icahn was ready. He had assembled thousands of replacement workers in Kansas City — recruits with as few as eighteen days of training — and deployed them immediately. He obtained a court order compelling the machinists to cross the picket lines. When the attendants made an unconditional offer to return to work in May 1986, Icahn informed them their positions had been permanently filled. Of approximately 5,100 who had walked out, fewer than 200 positions were initially offered back. It took three years of litigation before reinstatement was made available — three years of financial hardship and careers in suspension — while the company Icahn had promised to build was being dismantled, asset by asset.

The Leveraged Cannibalism

In 1988, Icahn took the airline private in a leveraged buyout financed with approximately $1.5 billion in high-yield junk bonds arranged through Drexel Burnham Lambert, carrying interest rates between 17 and 22 percent. The structure was straightforward in its design and devastating in its consequences: Icahn received $469 million in cash. Trans World Airlines received $540 million in new debt. The airline — already weakened by three rounds of union concessions and the competitive pressures of deregulation — was now required to service interest obligations pilots’ union representatives estimated at $466 million annually on a total debt burden of $2.8 billion. No operational improvement could have made that arithmetic survivable. That was not a miscalculation. It was the point.

In 1991, facing default after missing $75.5 million in debt payments, Icahn sold what every analyst acknowledged was the crown jewel of TWA’s international network: its transatlantic routes to London’s Heathrow Airport, sold to American Airlines for $445 million. Combined with the Chicago-London route sold separately, Icahn had extracted from TWA’s route structure nearly $555 million — roughly equivalent to the entire debt burden he had loaded onto the airline in the 1988 buyout. Three unions and the city of St. Louis challenged the sales in federal court. A divided appeals court, in a 2-1 ruling, allowed them to proceed. In January 1992, TWA filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

img 4030

The Karabu Wound

Icahn resigned as TWA chairman in 1993 as part of the bankruptcy reorganization. But before he left, he secured one final instrument of ongoing extraction. It was called the Karabu Ticket Program Agreement, and it was negotiated as part of the debt settlement between Icahn, the airline’s creditors, its unions, and the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation.

Under Karabu’s terms, Icahn — through a corporate entity called Karabu Corp. — gained the right to purchase any TWA ticket connecting through the St. Louis hub at 55 cents on the dollar, for a period of eight years. The deal was supposedly structured to prevent him from competing through travel agents — the standard distribution channel of the era. But the architects of the agreement had failed to account for the internet. Icahn immediately established Lowestfare.com and began selling deeply discounted TWA tickets directly to consumers online.

Every ticket sold through Lowestfare.com was a ticket sold below the price TWA needed to sustain its operations. The airline could not raise fares on its own routes without watching Icahn undercut them online. It could not control its own revenue on traffic flowing through its primary hub. American Airlines, which acquired TWA in 2001, later estimated that the Karabu agreement had cost the airline $100 million per year for each year it remained in force.

While Icahn’s ticket arrangement drained the airline’s revenue, a second crisis was building. Through another corporate entity called Pichin Corp., Icahn had assumed responsibility for minimum funding payments on two defined-benefit pension plans covering approximately 36,500 TWA employees and retirees — along with the right to terminate those plans unilaterally after January 1, 1995. In late 2000, with TWA’s third bankruptcy approaching, he exercised that right. At termination, the Pilots’ Pension Plan was underfunded by $200 million. The Employees’ Pension Plan was underfunded by more than $500 million. The combined $700 million shortfall was transferred to the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation — to American taxpayers. A federal appeals court upheld the termination in 2003. More than 1,000 pensioners found themselves receiving up to $1,500 per month less than what they had been promised when they accepted Icahn’s concessions in 1986.

In January 2001, TWA filed for bankruptcy for the third and final time. American Airlines absorbed its routes. The TWA pilots were “stapled” to the bottom of American’s seniority list — a devastating term of art in aviation, where seniority governs everything from route assignments to retirement income. The flight attendants fared no differently: those who had walked the picket line in 1986, who had spent years in litigation to reclaim their positions, who had outlasted Icahn’s replacement workers and returned to rebuild their careers, were also stapled to the bottom of American’s flight attendant seniority list — erasing decades of accumulated standing in a single administrative stroke. The Saarinen terminal at JFK was mothballed, then converted into a hotel. The pensions, the careers, and the promises were not part of the conversion.

The Same Playbook, Different Victims

What Icahn did to TWA was not unique. It was a refinement of a model applied across the American economy throughout the 1980s and 1990s. The core elements were consistent: acquire through leverage, extract through asset sales, redirect proceeds to the acquirer rather than the company’s operations, and exit before the structural damage becomes irreversible — or use bankruptcy as a final extraction tool.

Revco D.S. Inc., the nation’s second-largest drugstore chain with 2,000 stores and 28,000 employees, was taken private in a 1986 LBO for approximately $1.5 billion, with roughly $800 million in junk bonds. The management group contributed $18.9 million of its own cash — a proportion so small relative to the debt that a court-appointed bankruptcy examiner later concluded the transaction may have constituted fraudulent conveyance, leaving the company insolvent the moment the buyout closed. Revco lost $59 million in its first post-LBO fiscal year and filed for Chapter 11 in July 1988 — at the time, the largest leveraged buyout failure in American history.

Toys “R” Us was acquired in 2005 by a consortium of KKR, Bain Capital, and Vornado Realty Trust in a $6.6 billion LBO that saddled the company with more than $5 billion in debt. Interest payments consumed $400 million annually — money that, in a business competing against Amazon and Walmart, was desperately needed for e-commerce investment and store modernization. Instead, it serviced debt while the private equity owners collected $183 million in management and advisory fees regardless of the company’s declining performance. When Toys “R” Us filed for Chapter 11 in September 2017, 33,000 employees lost their jobs, most without severance. Public pressure eventually forced Bain and KKR to establish a $20 million assistance fund — approximately $600 per displaced worker.

The Sears Holdings case may be the most architecturally complete expression of the sale-leaseback extraction model. Eddie Lampert simultaneously served as Sears’ largest shareholder, its largest creditor through his hedge fund ESL Investments, and — through his creation of Seritage Growth Properties in 2015 — its landlord. He engineered the sale of 235 Sears and Kmart store properties to Seritage for $2.7 billion, then charged Sears rent to occupy the buildings it had previously owned. He sold Lands’ End, Craftsman tools, and submitted a bid for Kenmore through ESL — the same fund controlling the company approving the sale. When Sears filed for Chapter 11 in October 2018, the pension fund was underfunded by $1.5 billion, 100,000 retirees faced potential benefit reductions, and 175,000 workers had already lost jobs across Sears and Kmart over the preceding decade. The court approved Lampert’s purchase of the company he had dismantled through a new entity called Transform Holdco. Five Sears stores remain open in the United States today.

What Was Taken

Call it what it was: organized extraction under the protection of law. The tools — leveraged acquisition, sale-and-leaseback, junk bond financing, pension termination rights buried in bankruptcy settlements — were legal because a legal system heavily influenced by financial industry lobbying had made them legal. Bankruptcy law placed financial creditors above workers. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 — ERISA, the federal law designed to protect workers’ pension benefits — contained gaps wide enough for Pichin Corp. to drive a $700 million shortfall through. ERISA required pension plan sponsors to meet minimum funding standards, but it also permitted plan termination under specific conditions, and the 1993 TWA bankruptcy settlement had explicitly granted Icahn’s entity the contractual right to trigger that termination unilaterally. When Pichin Corp. exercised that right in 2000, ERISA’s own architecture allowed the liability to be handed off to the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation — the federal insurer created by the same law — shifting the cost from the man who had created the shortfall to the American public. The Karabu agreement was upheld in court as a valid contract even as it destroyed the carrier it was parasitically attached to.

Icahn once described his TWA involvement as “the worst investment” he ever made. The comment was offered not as remorse but as arithmetic — the return had been suboptimal given the aggravation. He emerged from TWA having pocketed $469 million in the 1988 buyout, $445 million from the London route sales, and years of Karabu ticket revenue. The 36,500 workers whose pensions were terminated, the flight attendants whose careers were interrupted or ended, the pilots stapled to the bottom of a seniority list — they experienced something that the financial press, dazzled by deal mechanics, rarely thought to name plainly: they were robbed. Not with a weapon. With a contract, a bankruptcy filing, and a ticket agreement. But robbed nonetheless.

The Saarinen terminal at JFK is now a hotel — and in its way, it is an honest memorial. The swooping concrete, the soaring glass, the mid-century optimism frozen in every arch: the hotel remembers TWA as it was, and remembers it lovingly. That is worth something. What is harder to sit with is the knowledge of how it ended — that a building designed to welcome the future became a monument to what was taken from the people who built that future, flight by flight, year by year. The cocktails carry the old route names. The gift shop sells the old logo. The institution is honored. The wound is not.

Sources

Related Posts

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x